If you have been injured in an accident in Fresno and the insurance company is not offering fair compensation, your attorney may recommend moving into litigation. For many injury victims, that word — litigation — is unfamiliar and intimidating. It sounds complicated, expensive, and uncertain.
Understanding what litigation actually means, what each stage involves, and why it is often the most powerful tool available to injury victims demystifies the process and puts you in a position to make informed decisions about your case.
What Does Litigation Mean?
Litigation is the formal legal process of resolving a dispute through the court system. In a personal injury case, litigation begins when your attorney files a lawsuit — a legal complaint — in the appropriate California court against the party responsible for your injuries.
Filing a lawsuit does not mean your case will go to trial. In fact, the vast majority of personal injury cases in California — approximately 95% — settle before a jury ever hears the evidence. What litigation does is change the dynamics of the negotiation entirely. It creates court-imposed deadlines, requires the defense to produce evidence through the discovery process, and signals to the insurance company that their choice is now between paying fair value or facing a jury.
Litigation is not about punishment or revenge. California civil courts are designed to restore injured victims to where they would have been financially had the accident not occurred — through compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages.
Pre-Litigation vs. Litigation — What Is the Difference?
Most personal injury cases begin in what attorneys call the pre-litigation phase. This is everything that happens before a lawsuit is filed — the initial investigation, medical treatment, demand package preparation, and negotiation with the insurance company.
Pre-litigation is faster and less expensive. If the insurance company offers fair value during this phase, the case resolves without ever entering the court system. But pre-litigation also has a significant limitation: the insurance company controls the negotiation. They can delay, lowball, deny, and stall — because there are no court deadlines compelling them to move.
Litigation removes that control. Once a lawsuit is filed, the court sets a case management schedule with mandatory deadlines for discovery, motions, and trial. The insurance company can no longer simply ignore or delay your claim. They must engage — and they must produce evidence that your attorney can use.
For Fresno injury victims whose claims have been denied or undervalued, understanding when pre-litigation ends and litigation becomes necessary is one of the most important decisions in the case. Read our post on why insurance companies deny claims for a full breakdown of the tactics that make litigation necessary.
The Stages of Personal Injury Litigation in California
Stage 1: Filing the Complaint
Litigation begins when your attorney files a complaint — a formal legal document — in the appropriate California Superior Court. Fresno County cases are typically filed in Fresno County Superior Court. The complaint sets out the facts of the accident, the legal theories of liability, and the categories of damages you are seeking.
After filing, the defendant must be formally served with a copy of the complaint and a summons notifying them of the lawsuit and their obligation to respond. The defendant typically has 30 days to respond with an answer — a formal document in which they admit or deny the allegations and raise any legal defenses.
One critical point: the complaint must be filed before the statute of limitations expires. In California, the statute of limitations for most personal injury claims is two years from the date of the accident. For claims involving a government entity — a city vehicle, a dangerous road maintained by a public agency — you have only six months to file a government tort claim before the right to sue is extinguished. Read our full breakdown in our post on the personal injury statute of limitations in California.
Stage 2: Discovery
Discovery is the most substantive phase of litigation — and the one that most directly determines case value. During discovery, both sides have the legal right to obtain evidence from each other and from third parties. The tools of discovery include:
Depositions. Sworn out-of-court testimony taken before a court reporter. Your attorney will depose the defendant, key witnesses, and any expert witnesses designated by the defense. You will be deposed by the defense attorney. Deposition testimony is taken under oath and can be used at trial. Preparing for your deposition — understanding what to say, what not to say, and how to handle aggressive questioning — is one of the most important things your attorney will do with you during litigation.
Interrogatories. Written questions that the opposing party must answer under oath. Interrogatories are used to establish basic facts, identify witnesses, and lock in the opposing party’s positions on key issues.
Requests for Production of Documents. Formal demands for medical records, employment records, insurance policies, vehicle maintenance records, communications, and any other documents relevant to the case.
Requests for Admissions. Formal requests asking the opposing party to admit or deny specific facts. Admissions are binding and eliminate those issues from dispute at trial — streamlining the proceeding and removing uncertainty.
Independent Medical Examinations (IME). In personal injury cases, the defense is typically entitled to have the plaintiff examined by a physician of their choosing. These exams — misleadingly called “independent” — are conducted by doctors regularly retained by insurance companies. Their reports often minimize injury severity and become a central battleground at trial. Your attorney prepares you for the IME and challenges unfavorable findings with your treating physicians’ records and expert testimony.
Discovery is also where evidence emerges that affects case value — in both directions. Evidence that solidifies liability pushes the case toward settlement. Evidence of prior injuries or gaps in medical treatment gives the defense leverage. Thorough pre-litigation documentation — the kind our Fresno injury lawyers build from the first consultation — is what determines which direction that pressure flows.
Stage 3: Motions Practice
During and after discovery, both sides may file pre-trial motions — formal requests asking the court to rule on specific legal issues before trial. The most significant is the motion for summary judgment, in which the defense argues that there is no genuine dispute of material fact and that they are entitled to judgment as a matter of law without a trial.
Successfully opposing a summary judgment motion requires your attorney to demonstrate that disputed facts exist that must be resolved by a jury — which is why evidence gathered during discovery is so critical. A poorly documented case with weak liability evidence is more vulnerable to summary judgment.
Other common motions include motions in limine — requests to exclude specific evidence from trial — which are filed after discovery closes and shape what the jury will actually hear.
Request a Free Consultation Today
Speak with an Attorney and understand your next steps
Stage 4: Mandatory Settlement Conference
California courts require the parties in most civil cases to attend a mandatory settlement conference (MSC) before trial. This is a judge-supervised session in which both sides present their positions and a judge assists in facilitating settlement discussions.
The MSC is not binding — neither party is required to settle. But it represents a significant opportunity. The participating judge often provides candid assessments of the case’s strengths and weaknesses, which can move both sides toward realistic valuations. Many Fresno personal injury cases resolve at or shortly after the mandatory settlement conference.
Stage 5: Mediation
In addition to the court-mandated settlement conference, parties frequently engage in private mediation — a voluntary process facilitated by a neutral third party, typically a retired judge or experienced mediator. Unlike the mandatory settlement conference, private mediation can be scheduled at any time during litigation, and both sides control the process.
Mediation is confidential. Statements made during mediation cannot be used as evidence at trial. The mediator does not make decisions — they facilitate negotiation between the parties, presenting each side’s position to the other in an effort to find common ground.
A significant percentage of California personal injury cases resolve through mediation. When both sides have invested in discovery and understand the evidence, the risks of trial become clearer — and settlement becomes more attractive for everyone.
Stage 6: Trial
If the case does not settle — through pre-trial negotiation, the mandatory settlement conference, or mediation — it proceeds to trial. California personal injury trials are jury trials unless both parties agree to a bench trial decided by the judge alone.
Trial proceeds in the following stages:
Voir dire — jury selection. Both attorneys question prospective jurors and have the opportunity to remove jurors for cause (demonstrated bias) or through peremptory challenges (without stated reason). Jury selection in Fresno County reflects the community’s composition and values — and experienced local attorneys understand how to select juries that are receptive to their clients’ cases.
Opening statements. Each attorney presents an overview of what the evidence will show. This is not argument — it is a roadmap of the case. Effective opening statements frame the narrative that jurors will use to interpret the evidence as it comes in.
Presentation of evidence and witness testimony. Both sides present their evidence — medical records, accident reconstruction, expert testimony, lay witness accounts, photographs, video — through direct examination of their own witnesses and cross-examination of the opposing side’s witnesses. This is the core of trial and the stage where preparation and experience matter most.
Closing arguments. Each attorney summarizes the evidence and argues for the verdict they believe the evidence supports. Closing arguments are advocacy at its most direct — asking the jury to apply the facts to the law and render a just verdict.
Jury instructions and deliberation. The judge instructs the jury on the applicable law using California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI). The jury then deliberates privately and returns a verdict. In Fresno County, personal injury verdicts reflect the community’s values and lived experience — which is why local knowledge and trial preparation matter enormously.
Section 998 Offers — A Critical Litigation Tool
One of the most strategically important tools in California personal injury litigation is the Section 998 offer to compromise under California Code of Civil Procedure Section 998. Either party can make a formal statutory offer of judgment at any time at least 10 days before trial.
If the plaintiff makes a 998 offer and the defense rejects it, then at trial the plaintiff wins more than the offer amount — the defense must pay the plaintiff’s expert witness fees incurred after the offer was rejected. This creates powerful incentive for the insurance company to take settlement offers seriously.
In 2025, the California Supreme Court clarified in Madrigal v. Hyundai Motor America that 998 cost-shifting applies even to pre-trial stipulated settlements less favorable than a prior 998 offer — making the strategic use of these offers even more significant in current litigation.
How Long Does Personal Injury Litigation Take in California?
Timeline varies significantly based on case complexity, injury severity, and court scheduling. General ranges for Fresno County personal injury litigation:
- Cases that settle shortly after filing: 3 to 6 months after the complaint is filed
- Cases that settle during discovery or at the mandatory settlement conference: 12 to 18 months after filing
- Cases that proceed to trial: 2 to 3 years after filing in most Fresno County Superior Court cases
The single biggest driver of timeline is how long it takes to reach maximum medical improvement — the point where your doctors can fully assess your long-term prognosis. Settling before MMI means settling before you know the full value of your claim. Read our post on the personal injury claim settlement process in California for a complete timeline from accident to resolution.
What Does Litigation Cost — and Who Pays?
Personal injury attorneys in California — including our Fresno injury lawyers — work on a contingency fee basis. You pay nothing unless your attorney recovers compensation for you. There are no upfront fees, no hourly charges, and no out-of-pocket costs to begin litigation.
The contingency fee is a percentage of the gross recovery — typically in the range of 33% for pre-litigation settlements and 40% for cases that proceed through trial, though the specific percentage is agreed upon at the outset of representation. Case costs — filing fees, deposition costs, expert witness fees, investigation costs — are typically advanced by the attorney and deducted from the recovery at the end of the case.
For a complete breakdown of how attorney fees work in California personal injury cases, read our post on how much lawyers take from settlements in California.
Why Litigation Produces Better Outcomes
The decision to move into litigation is not about wanting to go to court — it is about leverage. Insurance companies evaluate claims based on risk. A claim that is fully documented, well-organized, and represented by an attorney who is credibly prepared to take the case to trial is worth more to the insurer to settle — because the alternative is a jury, and juries in Fresno County take seriously the real-world impact of serious injuries.
This is why the Fresno car accident, truck accident, motorcycle accident, pedestrian accident, and wrongful death cases we handle at Dhanjan Injury Lawyers are prepared for trial from day one — even when the goal is a fair settlement. That preparation is what drives insurance companies to settle at full value rather than risk a jury verdict.
Frequently Asked Questions — Litigation in Personal Injury Cases
Does filing a lawsuit mean my case will go to trial?
No. Approximately 95% of personal injury cases in California that proceed into litigation settle before trial. Filing a lawsuit puts pressure on the insurance company and creates court deadlines — which often motivates the insurer to negotiate more seriously. Trial is the final option when all other resolution paths fail.
What is a deposition and do I have to participate?
A deposition is sworn out-of-court testimony taken before a court reporter. In a personal injury case you will be deposed by the defense attorney — it is a required part of the litigation process. Your attorney will prepare you thoroughly for your deposition, explaining what to expect, how to answer questions accurately, and how to avoid common mistakes that damage case value.
Can I still settle my case after a lawsuit is filed?
Yes — and most cases do. Settlement negotiations continue throughout the litigation process. Cases settle at every stage — after the complaint is filed, during discovery, at the mandatory settlement conference, during mediation, and even during trial. Filing a lawsuit does not close the door to settlement; it often opens it by demonstrating your commitment to pursuing full compensation.
What happens at a case management conference in California?
A case management conference is an early court hearing where the judge sets the case schedule — discovery deadlines, motion deadlines, and trial date. Both attorneys attend and the judge may ask questions about the status of the case and the likelihood of settlement. Our post on what to know about a case management conference in California covers this stage in detail.
How does comparative fault affect my case at trial?
California’s pure comparative negligence law applies at trial just as it does in settlement negotiations. The jury assigns a percentage of fault to each party and reduces the plaintiff’s total damages by their assigned percentage. Insurance companies use litigation to argue for higher fault assignments against the plaintiff — which is why evidence that clearly establishes the defendant’s liability is the foundation of every trial-ready case. Read our post on California’s comparative negligence law for the full explanation.